5.8.2 Default Reductions

After parser table construction, Bison identifies the reduction with the largest lookahead set in each parser state. To reduce the size of the parser state, traditional Bison behavior is to remove that lookahead set and to assign that reduction to be the default parser action. Such a reduction is known as a default reduction.

Default reductions affect more than the size of the parser tables. They also affect the behavior of the parser:

• Delayed yylex invocations.

  A consistent state is a state that has only one possible parser action. If that action is a reduction and is encoded as a default reduction, then that consistent state is called a defaulted state. Upon reaching a defaulted state, a Bison-generated parser does not bother to invoke yylex to fetch the next token before performing the reduction. In other words, whether default reductions are enabled in consistent states determines how soon a Bison-generated parser invokes yylex for a token: immediately when it reaches that token in the input or when it eventually needs that token as a lookahead to determine the next parser action. Traditionally, default reductions are enabled, and so the parser exhibits the latter behavior.

  The presence of defaulted states is an important consideration when designing yylex and the grammar file. That is, if the behavior of yylex can influence or be influenced by the semantic actions associated with the reductions in defaulted states, then the delay of the next yylex invocation until after those reductions is significant. For example, the semantic actions might pop a scope stack that yylex uses to determine what token to return. Thus, the delay might be necessary to ensure that yylex does not look up the next token in a scope that should already be considered closed.

• Delayed syntax error detection.

  When the parser fetches a new token by invoking yylex, it checks whether there is an action for that token in the current parser state. The parser detects a syntax error if and only if either (1) there is no action for that token or (2) the action for that token is the error action (due to the use of %nonassoc). However, if there is a default reduction in that state (which might or might not be a defaulted state), then it is impossible for condition 1 to exist. That is, all tokens have an action. Thus, the parser sometimes fails to detect the syntax error until it reaches a later state.

  While default reductions never cause the parser to accept syntactically incorrect sentences, the delay of syntax error detection can have unexpected effects on the behavior of the parser. However, the delay can be caused anyway by parser state merging and the use of %nonassoc, and it can be fixed by another Bison feature, LAC. We discuss the effects of delayed syntax error detection and LAC more in the next section (see section LAC).

For canonical LR, the only default reduction that Bison enables by default is the accept action, which appears only in the accepting state, which has no other action and is thus a defaulted state. However, the default accept action does not delay any yylex invocation or syntax error detection because the accept action ends the parse.

For LALR and IELR, Bison enables default reductions in nearly all states by default. There are only two exceptions. First, states that have a shift action on the error token do not have default reductions because delayed syntax error detection could then prevent the error token from ever being shifted in that state. However, parser state merging can cause the same effect anyway, and LAC fixes it in both cases, so future versions of Bison might drop this exception when LAC is activated. Second, GLR parsers do not record the default reduction as the action on a lookahead token for which there is a conflict. The correct action in this case is to split the parse instead.

To adjust which states have default reductions enabled, use the %define lr.default-reduction directive.

Directive: %define lr.default-reduction where

Specify the kind of states that are permitted to contain default reductions. The accepted values of where are:

• most (default for LALR and IELR)
• consistent
• accepting (default for canonical LR)

(The ability to specify where default reductions are permitted is experimental. More user feedback will help to stabilize it.)

This document was generated on December 1, 2013 using texi2html 5.0.